Confronting Memoricide and Minstrelsy at the JNF’s “Broadway Sensation” Fundraiser

Pro-Israel commentators are generally loath to engage in discussions of the history surrounding Israel’s creation. When they do, they generally resort to tired and discredited myths about the Palestinians running away at their leaders’ behest, or about the Nakba being “self-inflicted,” as Jeffrey Goldberg said recently. Nakba denial is an important feature of hasbara, not only because acknowledging the real history of Palestinian dispossession in 1947, ’48 and in the years afterwards erodes the foundation of the Zionist narrative, but because the Nakba continues on both sides of the Green Line to this day.

Besides the Israeli army, there is no single organization more intimately involved in the ongoing Nakba than the Jewish National Fund. Originally called the Jewish Colonial Trust, the JNF was in charge of buying land from absentee landlords, then evicting thousands of tenants and residents in Palestine, transforming an entire agricultural class into landless peasants. In the 1930′s, JNF director Yosef Weitz helped lead David Ben Gurion’s Transfer Committee, which planned the widespread campaign ethnic cleansing that would take place beginning in 1947, one year before the foundation of Israel. After the state confiscated millions of dollars of Palestinian land and property, it began leasing it out through the JNF, which declares in its charter that it only leases to Jews. The JNF also planted non-native forests on top of dozens of destroyed Palestinian villages so their residents would have nothing to return to — greenwashing in its ultimate form. (Everything I have referenced is described in greater detail here).

Nowadays, the JNF is leading a violent campaign to expel the Bedouin residents of Al Arakib, a village in the Negev Desert so it can build a forest on behalf of GOD TV, an anti-Semitic evangelical broadcasting network that says it is planting trees in Israel to prepare the land for Christ’s return. Talk about an unholy alliance. The residents of Al Arakib, who have been shot by rubber bullets, beaten, and jailed, have been ordered to move to a “development town” (read: Indian reservation) built by the Or Movement, a JNF subsidiary. For a comprehensive look at the JNF’s seamy agenda and long record of human rights violations, go to the link above and check out the four volume JNF e-book series (my writing and reporting is featured in two editions).

On May 16, a day after worldwide Nakba observances, me and a few friends confronted attendees of a JNF fundraising event in New York’s Lincoln Center called “Broadway Sensation.” We handed out small trees planted next to small cards featuring the names of ethnically cleansed Palestinian villages. The prop allowed us to attempt to discuss the history of the Nakba and the JNF’s role in it with some of the JNF’s major donors. Their hostility to engaging with us was revealing. They knew nothing about the JNF’s involvement in ethnic cleansing and didn’t want to know. Before long we were asked to leave by security guards.

On our way out we noticed on a flier for the event that the JNF’s donors were being entertained by the Scottsboro Boys, a Broadway show about a group of African-Americans wrongly convicted of rape. While some have hailed the show as humorous and well-choreographed, the African-American theater and arts critic Valerie Gladstone called it “a callous production in…questionable taste.” It’s hard to blame her for being so harsh. After all, the musical is a literal minstrel show that is performed during parts by black actors wearing blackface.

Here is a taste of the entertainment the JNF selected for its donors:

3 thoughts on “Confronting Memoricide and Minstrelsy at the JNF’s “Broadway Sensation” Fundraiser

  1. AdamAW

    Thanks Max, and well done to all you guys for keeping your cool. The incident with the photographer was particularly humorous!

    I myself was misinformed about this having taken a little too literally the description of events given by ‘Nazi hunter’ Simon Wiesenthal in the chapter in his book Justice not Vengeance in which he defends the state of Israel.

    Good to be better informed about matters, and particularly important to know that the efforts to ethnically cleanse the area preceded 1948, and also carried on afterwards.

  2. DICKERSON3870

    RE: “Here is a taste of the entertainment the JNF selected for its donor [Scottsboro Boys]” – Max

    MY SNARK: Are they in “blackface”? I just love “step n fetch” a/k/a Stepin Fetchit, step-n-fetch, “step and fetch it”, etc! Those “boys” look like they are so happy to be dancin’ for rich white folks! It reminds me of the Good Old Jim Crow Days! “Oh mammy, my little mammy, I’d walk a million miles for one of your smiles, My mammy.”

    P.S. Only in Israel would a new high-rise residence building proudly bear the name “White City”! It is so reminiscent of South Africa, circa 1980.
    White City Residence, Tel Aviv – http://www.emporis.com/building/elhanantower-telavivyaffo-israel

Leave a Reply