Forgotten 1963 Survey: Majority Of Israeli Jewish Youth Could Support Genocide Against Arabs

In my recent post about the “summer camp of destruction,” I cited figures from Israeli social psychologist Daniel Bar-Tal’s survey on the political attitudes of Jewish Israeli high school students. In polling conducted in the aftermath of Operation Cast Lead, Bar-Tal found that a majority of Israeli high schoolers favored at least some form of apartheid, and that the desire for apartheid among religious nationalist youth was nearly universal. The disturbing findings have been generally read as a reflection of Israel’s comprehensive shift to the hard right since the collapse of the so-called peace process (see Bar-Tal’s polling on Israeli attitudes toward territorial concessions here). But there is considerable evidence that a majority of Jewish Israeli youth had been been successfully conditioned to consent to indiscriminate violence against Arabs well before the most recent phase of radicalization, and years before the occupation of the West Bank and Gaza even began.

Akiva Orr was a founder of the leftist group Matzpen, the first organized Israeli group to renounce Zionism and urge a joint struggle with Palestinians against the occupation. Orr has been a swimming champion in Mandate Palestine, a soldier in Israel’s War of Independence, a neighbor of David Ben Gurion, and a leader of the movement to free Israeli nuclear whistleblower Mordechai Vanunu (who is finishing out a grueling prison sentence for violating the onerous terms of his release). His unique perspective makes him one of the most valuable but under-acknowledged analysts of Israeli society from its earliest days.

In his excellent collection of essays, “Israel: Politics, Myths, and Identity Crises,” Orr explored in detail the political attitudes of the generation born in independent Israel immediately after 1948. He identified the first curriculum approved by the Ministry of Education as a key factor in the radicalization of this generation of youth. Orr wrote, “Already in the early 1950′s special lessons on ‘Jewish consciousness’ were introduced into all schools to inculcate Jewish identity into the minds of the very young. These lessons present Jewish history as a unique — and inexplicable — martyrology… The motto is: ‘Masada will never fall again.’”

Orr described a document that exposed the consequences of indoctrinating the young and impressionable: A 1963 poll published by the Israeli psychologist G. Tamarin entitled, “A Pilot Study in Chauvinism: The Influence of Ethnico-Religious Prejudices on Moral Judgment.” Tamarin’s research compiled responses by over 1000 Jewish Israeli schoolchildren of ages 8 to 14 to two texts. (The children represented a broad range of social groups and classes spanning the whole of Israeli society — only Arab students were exempted). The first part of the first text presented to the children read:

You are well acquainted with the following passages from the book of Joshua: “So the people shouted when the priests blew the trumpets; and it came to pass when the people heard the sound of the trumpet and the people shouted with a great shout and the wall fell down flat, so that they people went into the city every man straight ahead and they took the city. And they utterly destroyed all that was in the city, both man and woman, young and old, and ox, and sheep, and ass with the edge of the sword. (VI, 20, 21) And that day Joshua took Makkedah, and smote it with the edge of the sword and the kings thereof he utterly destroyed and all the souls that were therein; he let none remain in it; but did unto the king thereof as he did unto the king of Jericho.”

After reading the passage, the children were asked the following questions:

1. Do you think that Joshua, and the Sons of Israel acted right or not? Explain your view.

2. Suppose the Israeli army conquers an Arab village in battle. Do you think it would be proper to act against the inhabitants as did Joshua with the people of Jericho and Makkedah? Explain your view.

600 of the children expressed total approval of Joshua’s destruction of Jericho and the application of his methods to the Arabs. Only 200 totally disapproved while 200 expressed mixed feelings — either partial approval or disapproval.

The same children were then presented with a version of the same story taken from ancient Chinese history:

General Lin, who founded the Chinese kingdom some 3000 years ago went to war with his army to conquer them a land. They came to some great cities with high walls and strong fortresses. The Chinese War God appeared to General Lin in a dream and promised him victory, ordering him to kill all living souls in the cities, because these people belonged to other religions. General Lin and his soldiers took the towns and utterly destroyed all that was therein, both man and woman, young and old, and ox and sheep, and ass with the edge of the sword. After destroying the cities they continued their way conquering many countries.

Only 70 children among the group of over 1000 totally approved of General Lin’s methods. 750 totally disapproved while the rest expressed mixed feelings.

Here is a breakdown of Tamarin’s findings:

On the Joshua question:  (A) 60% (B) 20% (C) 20%

On the General Lin q:                 7%        18%        75%

A = total approval

B = partial approval or disapproval

C = total disapproval

Why did a majority of the children support applying Joshua’s destruction of Jericho to the Arabs, while strongly rejecting the methods of the non-Jewish General Lin? Tamarin published a few of the children’s justifications:

The Israeli army would have acted rightly if it acted towards the Arabs as Joshua acted towards the people of Jericho and Makeddah. I think so because if they would have left the people and the city, the Arabs would have invaded the city and fought them.

I think they acted well, as Joshua did, because the Arabs want us to believe in their idols.

Joshua and the Sons of Israel did not act well, as they could have spared the animals for themselves.

Joshua acted properly because the people who inhabited the land were of a different religion, when Joshua killed them he wiped their religion from the earth.

When Tamarin released his research, Tel Aviv University refused to publish it. His findings only reached the public when they were read aloud during a meeting of the Israeli Psychological Society in November 1963. When Tamarin’s data was finally reported by the Israeli press, it caused a major uproar. In a cold and clinical fashion, he had informed the Israeli public that their children had been conditioned to approve of hypothetical acts of genocide against their Arab neighbors, if not to become active participants in a real genocide. Yet instead of prompting calls for reforming the education system, Tamarin’s research only invited widespread scorn.

Bar-Tal’s recent polls must be read in the light of Tamarin’s path-breaking study. Taken together, the surveys are evidence that the extremist political tendency of Jewish Israeli youth is not a new trend, but the intensification of a long process (Bar-Tal has been covering the phenomenon for years). And thanks to figures like Israeli Education Minister Gideon Saar, who endorsed Im Tirtzu’s McCarthyite campaign against academic critics of state violence, the process will grind on until well into the future.

13 thoughts on “Forgotten 1963 Survey: Majority Of Israeli Jewish Youth Could Support Genocide Against Arabs

  1. Tomeuntil

    Richard Dawkins talked about this polling of Tamarin in his book “The God Delusion”. There’s some point that should be made: It’s not very hard to connect the Israelites to the Israelis or the Plishtim to the Palestinians, for example, if you’re a child studying the bible in the state secular school. There’s a problem being a young jewish Israeli student studying the Torah aside history lessons, for him they both represent the truth.
    The problem would be risulted by abstaining the bible studies, but since I’m not delusional, teachers should declare at the classroom that the bible is a mythology, a collection of stories that don’t indicate any real-life past event, but that are studied only for the sake of tradition. But neither am I delusional about the intelligence of the Israeli Education ministers (for those who forgot- Limor Livnat of the Likud never finished high school).

  2. Racheli Gai

    I grew up in Israel in the 50′s and 60′s. I agree that anti-Arab brainwashing isn’t new, although it sounds like it’s gotten even worse…

    One correction: Saying that Vanunu “still languishes in prison” is misleading: He was out for some years now, although he wasn’t allowed to leave the country, and is under various ridiculous restrictions. – He is in Jail because he didn’t abide by some of them. (One would think that over eleven years of solitary confinement, and 18 years in prison altogether would have sufficed, but the vengeful spirit reigns supreme.)

  3. Yariv

    I agree with most of what you write.

    Tomeuntil, I do not agree with the way you paint bible studies in school. When we were studying the bible it was in a critical fashion, e.g. having been told that it has been written by many authors.

    Max, I find the use of this YouTube video demagogic and quite distasteful. It shows pictures out of context and hints at the interpretation one should reach by means of association and soundtrack. Had I shown you pictures of European kids playing with swords in European museums, would you have also assumed that they will grow up to use these swords on their neighbors?

  4. Tomeuntil

    Yariv, I was mostly talking about the bible lessons at the elementary school and junior high school. this range of ages is critical to your sense of judgment, and if the teacher doesn’t distinguish between history and the bible you’re very likely to consider them both the truth. It’s not that I’m against a cognitive dissonance, on the contrary, it usually gets you further to the truth. The problem is if one of the components that made the dissonance is a mythology, then you’re being misled.

    In the secular state high school you do analyze the text, but you don’t analyze the truthfulness of the text. My teacher didn’t say that it was written by many authors although she admitted to be an atheist. The point is that if you don’t have an overall policy that negates the truthfulness of the text in the secular high school, you actively encourage young Israelis that they’re the Israelites and the Arabs are the Goyim.

  5. Pingback: Besondere Leseempfehlungen 06.08.10 … kommentiert « Der AmSeL-Gedanke Plus = Gemeinschaft

  6. Sumud

    Max, on that recent survey of Israeli school students, well, Haaretz reporting on the survey was sanitised. Ynet News also reported on it, more honestly:

    ‘Poll: 46% of high-schoolers don’t want equality for Arabs’
    http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3861161,00.html

    Most alarming, and along similar lines to the 1963 survey you cite:

    “The poll showed that many students believe the phrase “Death to Arabs” is racist, and, therefore, not legitimate. Forty-five percent of religious students and 16% of secular students, however, believe it is a legitimate statement.”

    If you haven’t already it might be worth your while to contact the author of the survey and ask for a copy of it, in it’s entirety. It deserves more coverage than it received, especially stateside.

  7. Pingback: BLUMENTHAL: Forgotten 1963 survey – majority of Israeli Jewish youth could support genocide against Arabs

  8. hophmi

    What silly nonsense. And the children grew up and killed millions of Palestinians. Except that they didn’t.

    Maybe, just maybe, this has something to do with the conflict, given the obvious disparity between the first question and the second. What are the statistics on the Arab side?

  9. lpca520

    I hope you have a nice day! Very good article, well written and very thought out. I am looking forward to reading more of your posts in the future.
    xiaoxiao123 09 04

  10. monclerjacketssale

    moncler
    moncler jacket
    montcler jackets
    moncler coats
    moncler coats sale
    giubbotti moncler
    moncler uomo
    moncler sales
    moncler sale
    punti vendita moncler
    moncler daunenjacke
    moncler roma
    moncler winterjas
    moncler winterjassen
    moncler coat
    moncler down jackets
    moncler vest sale
    moncler down jacket
    moncler torino
    moncler jacket women
    moncler ski
    moncler jacket sale
    moncler jackets on sale
    moncler jackets for women
    moncler mens
    moncler dames
    moncler jackets for men
    moncler vanoise
    moncler mantel
    moncler jas dames
    moncler down coat
    abbigliamento moncler
    moncler ski jackets
    moncler herren
    moncler clothes
    moncler price
    moncler veste
    mountain equipment down jacket
    moncler munchen
    moncler discount
    manteau moncler
    moncler discount
    moncler damen
    felpe moncler
    moncler jackets for kids
    moncler kaufen
    moncler
    moncler sauterne
    pink moncler
    moncler coats for women
    moncler shirts
    moncler coats sale
    moncler schweiz
    moncler nantes hooded down coat
    moncler outerwear
    moncler vest men
    moncler deutschland
    moncler coats for men
    moncler shirt
    moncler winter jacket
    moncler sizing
    moncler coats on sale
    moncler sizing
    moncler berlin
    moncler tibet vest
    mens moncler coats
    cheap moncler coats
    moncler down jacket women
    moncler jackets online
    moncler winterjacken
    moncler jassen te koop
    moncler coats for kids
    moncler winterjacken
    moncler jassen te koop
    moncler ski wear
    moncler tulsa jacket
    moncler down vest
    moncler vest for women
    moncler herrenjacke
    moncler coats for cheap
    moncler herrenjacke
    real moncler jackets
    moncler kindermode
    moncler zomerjas
    moncler leather jackets
    moncler summer jacket
    moncler spring jackets
    moncler down jacket
    moncler jackets for men
    moncler coats
    moncler ski jackets
    leather jackets
    moncler jacket
    mens leather jackets
    moncler jackets on sale
    moncler jackets for women
    moncler down jackets
    moncler uomo
    moncler outerwear
    moncler daunenjacke
    moncler spring jackets
    moncler roma
    moncler weste
    moncler discount
    moncler down coat
    moncler torino
    moncler vest men
    moncler munchen
    moncler price
    moncler jacket women
    moncler leather jackets
    moncler sales
    moncler sauterne
    moncler mens
    montcler jacken
    montclair ski jackets
    manteau moncler
    moncler jassen te koop
    abbigliamento moncler
    moncler sweater
    moncler ski wear
    moncler herren
    moncler schweiz
    moncler sizing
    moncler schweiz
    moncler sizing
    moncler zomerjas
    felpe moncler
    moncler tibet vest
    moncler dames
    moncler jas dames
    moncler deutschland
    moncler k2 jacket
    moncler winterjassen
    moncler berlin
    moncler down jacket women
    real moncler jackets
    moncler winterjacken
    moncler kindermode
    moncler damen
    moncler clothes
    moncler herrenjacke
    moncler winter jacket
    moncler winterjas
    moncler kaufen
    moncler coats
    moncler down jacket
    moncler jackets for men
    moncler coats for men
    moncler coat
    moncler coats for women
    moncler ski jackets
    moncler vest
    moncler jackets on sale
    moncler coats for kids
    moncler trench coat
    moncler men
    moncler vest men
    moncler bubble jacket
    moncler jacket
    moncler down jackets
    mens moncler coats
    giubbotti moncler
    moncler roma
    moncler daunenjacke
    moncler coats on sale
    moncler mantel
    moncler shirts
    moncler discount
    moncler torino
    moncler tulsa jacket
    moncler coats for cheap
    moncler jackets for women
    moncler weste
    moncler nantes hooded down coat
    moncler vanoise
    moncler munchen
    moncler summer jacket
    mountain equipment down jacket
    punti vendita moncler
    moncler ski
    moncler sales
    moncler mens
    montcler jacken
    moncler sizing
    manteau moncler
    moncler ski wear
    moncler jassen te koop
    moncler tibet vest
    moncler herren
    moncler schweiz
    moncler zomerjas
    felpe moncler
    moncler jackets online
    moncler sweater
    cheap moncler coats
    pink moncler
    moncler dames
    moncler jas dames
    moncler winterjassen
    moncler raincoat
    moncler shirt
    moncler winterjacken
    moncler damen
    moncler kindermode
    moncler vest for women
    moncler jacket sale
    moncler günstig
    moncler jacket women
    moncler herrenjacke
    moncler ski pants
    moncler winterjas
    moncler down vest
    Moncler Womens Coats
    2010 ladies newest moncler jackets black
    2010 ladies newest moncler jackets orange
    2010 ladies newest moncler jackets pure blue
    2010 ladies newest moncler jackets purple
    2010 ladies newest moncler jackets red
    Moncler Lucie Pop Star Jacket Black
    Moncler Lucie Pop Star Jacket Black 2
    Moncler Lucie Pop Star Jacket Brown
    Moncler Lucie Pop Star Jacket Chocolate
    Moncler Lucie Pop Star Jacket DarkOrchid
    Moncler Lucie Pop Star Jacket Purple
    Moncler Lucie Pop Star Jacket White
    Moncler Womens Jacket
    Ladies Moncler Fashion Down Coat Black
    Ladies Moncler Fashion Down Coat Blue
    Ladies Moncler Fashionable Down Coat Blue
    Ladies Moncler Fashionable Down Coat Brown
    Ladies Moncler Fashionable Down Coat Purple
    Ladies Moncler Fashionable Down Coat White
    MONCLER LIGHT NYLON SALLA DOWN JACKET
    Moncler Badia Very Shiny Black
    Moncler Women Classical Style Beige Down Coat
    Moncler Women Classical Style Black Down Coat
    Moncler Women Classical Style Blue Down Coat
    Moncler Mens Coats
    Fashion Moncler doudoune Rabbit men coats Cover buttocks
    Long Moncler Down Coats for men’s
    Moncler Cheap Opaque Sport Jacket
    Moncler Coats Hooded down mid length men Coffee
    Moncler Coats Hooded down mid length men Dark
    Moncler Coats men Hooded down jackets dark green
    Moncler Coats men Hooded down jackets nevy blue
    Moncler Discount Jackets 2010 Men Down Jacket
    Moncler Discount Sheepskin&Feather short Down black shop all Mon
    Moncler Down Coat men Hooded mid-length black
    Moncler down jacket man with hooded zip black
    Moncler Jackets Affton Half length Men Brown
    Moncler long down Coat brown
    Moncler long down Coat brown Gray
    Moncler long men down jackets Zegna grey
    Moncler Men Long Down Coats Grey
    Moncler Mens Jacket
    Branson Navy Mens Moncler Jackets Dark Blue
    Branson Navy Moncler Men Jackets Black
    Chartreuse Down Mens Moncler Jackets Grey
    Moncler Arcs Jacket black
    Moncler Aspen Down Jackets Black
    Moncler Branson Down Jacket Grey
    Moncler Bredford Jacket black
    Moncler Bulgarie Jacket black
    Moncler Bulgarie Jacket Brown
    Moncler Chamonix Jacket
    Moncler Chevalier Jacket black
    Moncler Down Jacket
    Moncler For Men Anderson Parka
    Moncler Himalaya Jacket black
    Moncler Himalaya Jacket doudoune brillante veste taille Brown
    Moncler Himalaya Jacket White
    Moncler Himalaya Jacket White
    Moncler Jackets For Men "Christmas Edition" Down Black
    Moncler K2 Jacket 3 Outwear Grey
    Moncler Maya Hooded Parka Navy
    Moncler Maya Jacket black
    Moncler Maya Jacket Purple
    Moncler Men Down Jacket Blue
    Moncler Men Down Jacket – Grey
    Moncler Men Down-Hat Jacket
    Moncler Men Down-No Hat Jacket
    Moncler Men Jacket -leon navy
    Moncler Mens Jacket Blue
    Moncler Mens Jackets Black
    Moncler Striped Technical Menuire Sport Jacket
    Quilted Moncler Ski Jackets with hood
    Moncler Men Sweater
    Moncler 90% of wool Sweater Gray men
    Moncler 90% of wool Sweater green men
    Moncler 90% of wool Sweater green men
    Moncler Cardigan 90% of wool Sweater black men
    Moncler men 90% of wool Sweater Black
    Moncler men 90% of wool Sweater Black
    Moncler men 90% of wool Sweater Black
    Moncler men 90% of wool Sweater Green and white
    Moncler men 90% of wool Sweater grey
    Moncler men 90% of wool Sweater grey
    Moncler men 90% of wool Sweater shallow and white
    Moncler men 90% of wool Sweater yellow and purple
    Moncler men black 90% of wool Sweater
    Moncler Sweater men black 90% of wool Sweater
    Moncler Sweater men black 90% of wool Sweater
    Moncler Sweater men black 90% of wool Sweater
    Moncler Sweater men blue 90% of wool Sweater
    Moncler Vest
    2010 new Moncler Vests For Women fur down gilet/vest Blue
    2010 new Moncler women fur down gilet/vest Black
    2010 new Moncler women fur down gilet/vest Purple
    2010 new Moncler women fur down gilet/vest Red
    Moncler Milano Multiple logo Women Vest Cream
    Moncler Multiple logo Women Vest Black
    Moncler Multiple logo Womens Vest Beige
    Moncler Multiple logo Womens Vest Black
    Moncler Tibet Vest – Quilted body warmer Navy
    Moncler vest sale waistcoat blue
    Moncler Spring Autumn
    Fashion Men Moncler Spring Autumn Jacket black
    Fashion Men Moncler Winter & Autumn Jacket black
    Fashion Men Moncler Winter & Autumn Jacket black
    Fashion moncler halesia women Spring Autumn Jacket Blue
    Fashion Moncler Men Spring Autumn Jacket blue
    Fashion Moncler Men Spring Autumn Jacket Cream
    Fashion Moncler Men Spring Autumn Jacket white
    Fashion Moncler women Spring Autumn Jacket black
    Fashion Moncler women Spring Autumn Jacket Gary
    Fashion Moncler women Spring Autumn Jacket Purple
    Fashion Moncler women Spring Autumn Jacket
    Fashion Moncler women Spring Autumn Jacket white
    Moncler Polo

Leave a Reply