IDF Releases Apparently Doctored Flotilla Audio; Press Reports As Fact

The IDF’s propaganda is increasingly unbelievable, yet the media is enthusiastically playing along. This audio, which purports to show flotilla passengers telling the IDF to “go back to Auschwitz,” appears to have been doctored by the IDF General Press Office or someone connected to it.

The clip originally released by the IDF on May 31 of its exchange with the Mavi Marmara, which is featured below, shows the IDF warning the ship’s crew, “Mavi Marmara, you are appproaching an area of hostility which is under a naval blockade. The Gaza area coastal region and Gaza harbor are closed to all maritime traffic…” The Mavi Marmara responded to the IDF’s warning: “Negative, negative. Our destination is Gaza. Our destination is Gaza.” There was no reference to Auschwitz in the video the IDF released on May 31.

The original video released by the IDF on May 31

On June 4, the IDF released apparently doctored audio of its exchange with the Mavi Marmara. The clip the IDF released featured the same imagery from its previous clip, but the voice of the Israeli Navy dispatcher was dramatically different. And the reply from the Mavi Marmara sounded like an impersonation of an Arab by a mentally challenged pre-adolescent (both videos are still on the IDF’s YouTube channel even though they completely contradict each other).

The video apparently doctored by the IDF, released on June 4

Further, the IDF is claiming its “Aushwitz” audio is from the Mavi Marmara. Yet it includes a recording of Huwaida Arraf saying “we have permission from the Gaza port authority to enter.” Huwaida has confirmed to the Institute For Middle East Understanding that her voice appeared in the apparently doctored clip. Unfortunately for the IDF, Huwaida was on the Challenger One, not the Mavi Marmara. How can the IDF account for this inconvenient discrepancy?

The Israeli daily, Yedioth Ahronot, which means “latest news,” are in fact the latest idiots. They’ve reported the apparently doctored audio clip as fact. And so has Haaretz. Haaretz has quietly changed its headline but the article remains stenographic in nature. Neither outlet made any effort to investigate the veracity of the IDF’s claims.

Either the mayor of Chelm is in charge of the IDF Press Office, or the Israeli military has something very ugly to hide.

Update: Ali Abunimah has also confirmed with Huwaida that her voice appeared in the apparently doctored IDF audio clip, but that she was not on the Mavi Marmara.

54 thoughts on “IDF Releases Apparently Doctored Flotilla Audio; Press Reports As Fact

  1. Pingback: Report: Autopsies Show Israelis Shot Flotilla Activists Repeatedly in Head at Point-Blank Range « SpeakEasy

  2. mbg

    Uh, is it glaringly obvious to anyone else that the audio of the second video, purporting to be an overdubbed version of the first, doesn’t match up with the “original” IDF video? Who created this video? It doesn’t have the IDF stamp. The “original video” doesn’t appear to be tampered with at all.
    i.e Video 1: “you are approaching an area of hostility which is under a naval blockade….”
    video 2: “you are approaching an area which under a naval blockade.”

  3. ersfma

    Where are the boats now – undergoing similar tampering and evidence cleansing? How about the money mentioned by Michael Oren in the NYTimes – the credit cards, socks and other items stolen from passengers?

  4. Pingback: The Lies Continue at LGF « Fear and War

  5. qumbr

    Those videos don’t contradict each other. IDF contacted and warned the ships of the flotilla many times, not just once. And while the first video is a footage from a ship, the second video is a recording of the radio (and not of the same call). And they just used an image that they had, it doesn’t mean anything.

  6. Max Post author

    Even if the second clip was real, which it clearly isn’t, it would contain audio transmissions from two different ships. Yet the IDF has presented the transmissions as from the same ship. Why even bother defending this moronic forgery?

  7. Pingback: Tax-Exempt US $$ Fund Tasteless Israeli Flotilla Satire « LobeLog.com

  8. Pingback: Israeler förfalskade videos från bordningen : Motbilder

  9. Jim Holstun

    Oh, it really is too wonderful! The third bit (the one by the Texas stoner) is also priceless–”Don fuhget nineleven, guys.” Who is the Director of Israel Military Intelligence? Beavis ben Butthead?

  10. Pingback: Max Blumenthal on why the Israeli government cannot Investigate the Flotilla disaster - Blog Post

  11. Pingback: Israel intercepts MV Rachel Corrie « A Conservative Shemale

  12. Pingback: ”Go back to Auschwitz” « Temet Nosce

  13. Pingback: Accusations that Flotilla “Auschwitz” Exchange Was Faked Exposed As, errr, Fake at Z-Word Blog

  14. Pingback: PsiOp Radio » PsiOp Radio 117 – 100606

  15. ufraidees0

    It’s glaringly obvious to me, this is doctored audio; there are VERY audible edit points, ‘bumps’ in the gain due to a lack of care to make it seamless. Done in a hurry by people whose expertise lies ‘elsewhere’.

  16. Pingback: Israel admits it altered flotilla audio - News

  17. Pingback: Israel admits it altered flotilla audio « Jared Malsin

  18. Pingback: Suburban Guerrilla » Blog Archive » Nothing They Won’t Try

  19. Pingback: “Shut up and Go Back to Auschwitz” (See TM Note – False Story) | Taylor Marsh – TaylorMarsh.com – News, Opinion and Weblog on Progressive Politics

  20. Pingback: Full Gaza flotilla radio communication: “Auschwitz-9/11-helping Arabs” « Tony Blair

  21. Pingback: I am thinking of buying an Hp slimline s3500t computer. Is it a good buy for gaming and HTPC? | Cordless Wireless Keyboard

  22. Pingback: JOURNALISTS TELL THE TRUTH AND GET DEPORTED, ISRAEL LIES AND GETS AWAY WITH IT « Desertpeace

  23. Pingback: Kayak2U Blog » Blog Archive » Tower of Babel

  24. Pingback: Israelis Explain, and Mock, Flotilla Clash - The Lede Blog - NYTimes.com

  25. Mosè

    We use to say: “the mother of the idiotis has never stopped giving birth.”
    The ID F continues with to give birth to so many of it.

  26. Pingback: rafaelrobles.com Vida de profesor » Provocadores

  27. Pingback: [Audio] IDF admits doctoring audio of raid on Gaza flotilla « Black Cafe Network News

  28. Pingback: » June 6, 2010, Page 2

  29. Pingback: The Truth Or The Fight » Blog Archive » IDF admits doctoring audio of raid on Gaza flotilla

  30. Pingback: IDF admits doctoring audio of raid on Gaza flotilla | War On You: Breaking Alternative News

  31. Pingback: Militant Libertarian » IDF admits doctoring audio of raid on Gaza flotilla

  32. Pingback: IDF admits doctoring audio of raid on Gaza flotilla | NWOTruth

  33. Pingback: FreeWestRadio.com » Blog Archive » IDF admits doctoring audio of raid on Gaza flotilla

  34. Pingback: IDF admits doctoring audio of raid on Gaza flotilla

  35. Pingback: The Crisis In Gaza — An International Tipping Point « Spotlight on Politics

  36. Pingback: Photographs of Battered Israeli Commandos Show New Side of Raid - The Lede Blog - NYTimes.com

  37. Pingback: NY Times Lede Blog Surveys IDF’s Sea of Lies

  38. torsion

    I assume that we will soon see a long article here about the cropped Reuters photos.

  39. Pingback: Max’s balls « Do Wacka Do

  40. gabi

    Oh, maybe these are the “fabricated and distorted” photos Mr. Blumenthal was referring to in one of his blogs earlier?!?

  41. Pingback: Israel to Release Flotilla Incident report on July 4th « LobeLog.com

  42. Pingback: Izraelská armáda zfalšovala nahrávku radiové komunikace z Mavi Marmarou, aby o?ernila posádku jako antisemity a teroristy « Sociologická trafika

  43. Pingback: Liberal PEPs Trash Helen Thomas While Ignoring Flotilla Deaths « Wallwritings

  44. Pingback: “Go back to Auschwitz” « Schmok

  45. Pingback: Týžde? - iný poh?ad na spolo?nos? » FACTCHECK F.Šebej: Turecká humanitárna avantúra II.

  46. Pingback: Busting the siege, American style

Leave a Reply