Another IDF Claim Unravels: IDF Unable To Support Claim Of Terrorists Aboard Flotilla Ship

The IDF has distributed a press release claiming that it has evidence that five passengers on the Mavi Marmara were “active terror operatives.” The army’s claims appeared thin at best, and patently false at worst. When I called the IDF Spokesman’s Office to ask for evidence, I was told there was none; all of the IDF’s claims were attributed to “intelligence” it could not share with reporters.

“The information in the statement comes based on intelligence,” Army spokesman Sgt. Chen Arad told me. “I don’t have any further information I can give.”

I pressed Arad to at least describe the intelligence he had seen. “There is very limited intelligence information we can give in this specific case,” he said. “Obviously I’m unable to give you more information.” He referred me to a colleague at the IDF’s North American desk. She did not answer after numerous tries. I’m going to call again tomorrow; journalist Lia Tarachansky has also placed a call to a spokesman and yielded similar responses which I’ll transcribe here soon.

One of the most bizarre accusations the IDF made was that former American citizen and ex-Marine Ken O’Keefe was planning to “train a commando unit” in the Gaza Strip. That’s the same Ken O’Keefe who organized an aid boat to Gaza, Aloha Palestine, with the sister-in-law of Tony Blair, Lauren Booth. In recent days, O’Keefe has been a major presence in the international media, giving his account of the melee on the deck of Mavi Marmara. Why would Hamas want some middle aged American guy with no experience in guerilla warfare to train its elite forces? The answer is the IDF is probably trying to smear O’Keefe to discredit his withering assessment of their conduct during the flotilla raid. “All I saw in Israel was cowards with guns,” O’Keefe has declared.

Hussein Arosh was implicated by the IDF for allegedly planning to “assist in smuggling Al-Qaeda operatives via Turkey into the Strip.” This claim is highly implausible. Why would Hamas allow Al Qaida operatives into the Gaza Strip when it is actively engaged in crushing any Al Qaida sympathizers who crop up within the territory it controls. Last year, Hamas forces killed 21 members of an Al Qaida inspired group in a battle in the Gaza Strip.

Another unusual IDF accusation was that the US resident Fatimah Mahmadi is a terrorist because she is “an active member of the organization ‘Viva Palestine'” who “attempted to smuggle forbidden electronic components into the Gaza Strip.” (I think the IDF means Viva Palestina, not Viva Palestine). Viva Palestina is not registered as a terrorist group by any country in the world; it is the British parliamentarian George Galloway’s pro-Palestine outfit, which is planning to organize more aid convoys.

The IDF’s press release did not appear credible in any way. If any reporters from the Israeli press had bothered to call the IDF to demand evidence, they would have learned that there was none. At least in Israel, the media is serving as a useful tool for the army. Just look at this piece by Haaretz’s Anshel Pfeffer.

12 thoughts on “Another IDF Claim Unravels: IDF Unable To Support Claim Of Terrorists Aboard Flotilla Ship

  1. Pingback: Flotilla passengers deny 'terrorist' charges - News

  2. ElGringo

    Ken O’Keefe claimed he had been beaten by Israelis several times while in detention, the last time at the deportation centre at Tel Aviv airport the night before his release. Given the obvious physical wounds inflicted (see ), couldn’t it be that the IDF came up with the ‘Ken O’Keefe is a terrorist’ press-release to minimize the impact of any eventual images/footage of O’Keefe, an ex US Marine, on US public opinion?

    Since it would be too obvious to just accuse O’Keefe of terrorism at the exact same moment he would appear before the media, the IDF fabricated some similar accusations against 4 other activists, to make it all look more ‘authentic’.

    I dunno, but with the blatant screw-ups we’ve seen sofar from the IDF Propaganda Squad, the above scenario would not suprise me at all!

  3. Pingback: Flotilla passengers deny ‘terrorist’ charges « Jared Malsin


  5. walt kovacs


    both the ihh and the ism (the parent org to the free gaza movement) have been tied to terrorist orgs.

    but max is too busy googling “i hate israel” to do any research on the sponsors of the flotilla

    and while max spends his time screaming about israel, turkey goes on massacring kurds

    bully for you max….a real humanitarian

    i think ill nominate you for the nobel pearce prize.

  6. Pingback: Flotilla Check: Facts and Israeli Lies | Sabbah Report

  7. Pingback: Flotilla Check: Facts and Israeli Lies « 800 Pound Gorilla

  8. Pingback: The Israeli Media’s Flotilla Fail

  9. Pingback: The New York Times can’t get their facts straight on Turkish IHH « Alex Kane

  10. Pingback: NYT Ties Turkish Group to ‘Terrorism’–by Mixing It Up With a Different Group - Fox News Watchdog

Leave a Reply